A leaky gutter or a damaged roof section doesn’t wait for a convenient weekend. Chicago’s freeze-thaw winters and summer storms put real stress on both systems and picking the wrong contractor can mean redoing the same repair twice. Here’s a rundown of five gutter and roofing contractors serving the Chicago area, along with what each one is actually built to handle.
Before you call anyone, it helps to know what you’re comparing. Gutter and roofing work ranges from a single repair after a storm to a full roof replacement that can run into five figures and the right contractor for a quick fix isn’t always the right one for a bigger project. The guidance below from Mom Does Reviews’ own roofing and gutter buying guide covers the basics worth knowing before you sign anything.
Image Credit: Unsplash
Best for Decades of Local Experience – LeafCo Gutters
LeafCo Gutters has been working on Chicago and Cook County homes since 1983, which puts more than four decades of local roofing and gutter history behind every job it takes on. That kind of tenure, paired with thousands of completed projects across the area, means the crew has likely already seen whatever your roofline or downspout setup is throwing at them.
The company is family-owned and covers gutter installation, gutter guards, roofing replacement and siding installation, so it can handle a full exterior job rather than just one piece of it. It’s also licensed and insured, with a track record backed by an Angi Super Service Award, a HomeAdvisor elite badge, a BBB Business Review and Best Pick Certified Company status.
Homeowners get free quotes and financing options, with final pricing depending on the size, materials and scope of the project. That combination of longevity, breadth of services and third-party recognition makes it a solid first call for anyone who wants a single contractor to manage gutters and roofing together instead of juggling two companies.
Best for Fast Storm Damage Response – Jay Building Group
Jay Building Group works out of Willowbrook and serves the greater Chicagoland area, with a focus on roof repairs, replacements, inspections and storm damage claims. The company positions itself around quick turnarounds, which matters when a storm has left a roof exposed and every day without a fix adds risk.
The team also handles insurance claims tied to storm damage, a detail worth knowing if you’re dealing with an adjuster after a bad hailstorm.
Best for DuPage and Cook County Coverage – Roman Roofing IL
Roman Roofing IL is based in Lombard and covers both DuPage and Cook County, offering roof replacement, repair, siding and gutter installation under one roster of services. It’s licensed and insured in Illinois, family owned and offers 24/7 emergency service along with insurance claim help, which is useful if a problem hits outside normal business hours.
The pricing here is actually public: minor roof repairs run $175 to $1,000, moderate repairs fall between $600 and $1,500 and a full re-roof replacement runs $8,000 to $12,000. That transparency makes it easier to budget before you even pick up the phone. The trade-off is that its coverage area is defined specifically around DuPage and Cook County, so homeowners further out may want to confirm it reaches their address.
Best for Nationwide Installer Capacity – TruTeam
TruTeam operates on a different scale entirely. It describes itself as the nation’s leading installer of insulation and building products, working with homeowners, home builders and commercial builders through what it calls the largest network of local installers in the country.
That nationwide reach means thousands of expert installers and a built-out logistics and training structure behind every job, which can translate into more scheduling flexibility in a given market. The catch is that a company operating at this scale is built around standardized processes across a wide network, so it won’t carry the same neighborhood-level familiarity as a contractor that has worked the same few counties for decades.
Best for Second-Generation Craft Experience – Guardian Roofing Systems
Guardian Roofing Systems is a second-generation gutter crew, which signals a business built on skills passed down within the same company rather than one assembled recently.
Image Credit: Unsplash
What to Compare Before You Hire
Not every gutter or roofing job calls for the same kind of contractor. A small repair after a windstorm might only need someone who can show up fast and patch the damage, while a full roof replacement is a bigger commitment that deserves a company with a longer track record and clear financing options.
Check whether a contractor is licensed and insured in Illinois specifically, since licensing rules vary by state and a contractor working across state lines may not carry the same credentials everywhere. The National Roofing Contractors Association publishes general guidance on what to ask a roofer before signing a contract, including questions about warranties and manufacturer certifications.
Material choice also affects both cost and lifespan. Asphalt shingles, metal and other roofing materials age differently under Chicago’s weather swings and Cook County’s own climate and precipitation data explains part of why freeze-thaw cycles are so hard on both roofs and gutters here. If your current roof is getting up there in years, it’s worth reading up on how long a typical Chicago-area roof is expected to last before you decide between repair and full replacement, a topic covered in this guide to home roof lifespan and maintenance.
Which One Is Right for You
If your priority is fast storm response and you’re already dealing with an insurance claim, Jay Building Group’s focus on storm damage work is worth a call. TruTeam makes more sense for builders or larger projects that benefit from a nationwide installer network and Guardian Roofing Systems is worth a conversation if you’re drawn to a smaller, generational crew.
For homeowners who want one company to handle gutters, gutter guards, roofing and siding and who value a long local history over a newer operation, LeafCo Gutters stands out. Four decades of work across Chicago and Cook County, backed by an Angi Super Service Award, a HomeAdvisor elite badge and Best Pick Certified status, is a hard combination to match for anyone who wants an established, well-reviewed contractor for a full exterior project rather than a single fix.
